What a good marketing agency should ask before it quotes you
Before any talk of budgets or platforms, a good agency wants to understand your offer, because no amount of advertising can make people want something they don't.
By Benjamin Simkin, CEO of BusinessNET
If you are choosing a marketing agency, the first thing a good one will want to understand is your offer. Advertising can only find people who already want what you sell, and it has no power to make them want it. An agency that will run ads for any offer you hand it, without asking whether anyone is hungry for it, is selling you activity. I have sat on the agency side of that first meeting since I started BusinessNET in 2005. The questions I ask before I quote anything are almost all about the offer and the numbers behind it, with very little about the ads themselves.
Why the offer decides what the ads can do
The idea goes back to Eugene Schwartz, who wrote in Breakthrough Advertising that copy cannot put desire into people. All it can do is find a desire that already exists in a lot of people and channel it onto a particular offer. Gary Halbert said the same thing in a way most owners remember. At his seminars he would let people open an imaginary hamburger stand with every advantage they could name, the best buns and the best location among them. For himself he asked for only one, a starving crowd, because hungry people don't need to be talked into eating.
He lived by it. In the 1980s the phone book was put onto computers for the first time, which meant you could address a letter to nearly every household in America. Halbert went looking for an offer that anyone at all would want to send him money for. At its height that mailing brought in $300,000 a day, with about 43 people whose whole job was carrying cheques to the bank. Very few of us should write to an entire country, so the lesson to take is where he started, with something people already wanted, which meant the letter only had to tell them it existed.
This is why I say to every owner that the offer decides what the advertising can do. Put a good offer in front of people who already want it and the ads become the easy part of the business. Put an offer nobody is hungry for in front of those same people and an agency can adjust the targeting and test new headlines every week for a year, which keeps everyone busy while the result barely moves.
The newspaper ad that sold $3 million
My first client taught me this before I knew enough to put it into words. Canterbury Property Services came to me by referral in 2005, when I had no marketing experience and had never built a website. I charged them $20,000 up front, rented a list of 10,000 people aged 30 to 55 in their city, scanned the newspaper advertisement they already had, and emailed it to that list without changing a word.
It produced $3 million in sales. I would love to say it was clever copywriting, but I didn't write any copy at all. The offer in that ad was already something people in that age group wanted, and my contribution was putting it in front of the right people. Over the following four and a half years Canterbury's turnover grew from $30 million a year to $115 million a year, and the business is now above $180 million a year.
Now run the same exercise with an offer that isn't ready. Say, as a plain hypothetical, that you email 10,000 well-chosen people and an offer they are hungry for brings back 60 enquiries. A weaker offer sent to the same list on the same day brings back 12. The list and the cost of sending are identical, so the whole difference sits in the offer. An agency that answers those 12 enquiries by asking you to double the budget will get you 24 of them at twice the price, and you will be no closer to a business that grows.
Why we have turned owners away
Because of this, BusinessNET has said no to owners whose offer wasn't ready for advertising. When someone asked us to do their marketing, we asked about the offer and the business model first. Sometimes the right answer was that we wouldn't run their ads until they had a better offer. It is an uncomfortable thing to tell someone who wants to pay you. Taking the fee would have meant spending their budget on reach that could never pay back, and both of us would have lost.
The agencies that never say no tend to sell something else instead, which is usually a promised number of leads a week. A few years ago every man and his dog became a marketing or social media agency, and they all made roughly the same promise in roughly the same words. Owners had no way of telling them apart, so they chose on price. If you have been through agency after agency and still aren't sure what went wrong, there is a fair chance none of them asked whether your offer was something people would love to pay for.
The questions to expect in a first meeting
A good first meeting feels more like an interview about your business than a pitch about the agency. These are the questions I work through, roughly in this order, before I would quote anything:
- How much revenue came in last month and this month, and how much of it was fresh front-end cash as against recurring revenue from people who had already bought?
- What is your net margin, since a big revenue figure can sit on top of a thin one and hide it?
- Where did your customers actually come from, in exact percentages rather than "mostly referrals and some ads"?
- What is the offer, what sits on your price ladder, how long does the sales cycle run, and how many deposits turn into closed sales?
- What is a customer worth over their whole time with you, and how long does it take to earn back what you spent to win them?
- Does your market even use your word for what you sell?
The order matters, because each answer tells me how far to trust the next one. If an agency skips straight to which platform and what monthly budget, put these questions to them about your own business and watch whether they care about the answers. You can also ask what they would need to see in your offer before they agreed to take you on, because an agency with no answer to that question will take anyone.
The most useful thing you can do this week has nothing to do with agencies. Write down what you sell the way a customer would describe the result they are paying for. Then ask yourself whether people would love to give you money for it, or would only agree after a long sales process. If it is the latter, that is where the work starts, and a good agency will tell you so before it sends you a quote.
Questions people ask
What should a marketing agency ask in the first meeting?
A good agency should ask about your offer, your revenue split between new and recurring customers, your margin, where your customers come from and what a customer is worth over time. If the conversation goes straight to platforms and budgets, the agency is quoting on activity without knowing whether the ads can pay back.
Why would a marketing agency turn down a client?
Usually because the offer isn't ready. Advertising can only find people who already want what you sell, so running ads for an offer nobody is hungry for spends your budget without a return. An agency that says no in that situation is protecting your money and its own results.
Can better ads fix a weak offer?
Not in any lasting way. Better targeting and headlines can lift the numbers a little, but if people don't want what you are offering, more reach mostly means more cost. The bigger gains come from improving the offer first and then putting it in front of people who already want it.